Strandhotels in Shelter Island

'It’s a beautiful property with a fun bar and delicious restaurant . The rooms were beautiful and the bed was super comfortable'

'Unique place but service too dependent on the individual server or concierge - some are incredible others are too slow and thereby under the level of this kind of accomodation '

'Room clean, bed comfy, high quality towels, friendly and accommodating customer service. Great areas in hotel to sit, read, relax Great location'

'We stayed at the Shoals for 3 nights. Something I didn't realize was that there are no rooms directly facing the water - all rooms look out to the parking lot. The property and rooms were very clean and very well maintained, however many things were lacking. 1.) MAJOR concern: We asked for a pack n play for our baby and they brought up a mattress with it. We looked up the mattress brand (Spring Spirit) and it was recalled in 2024!! Parents: please check all the items you receive!! We were...

'There is no where to sit outside at night unless you have a room with a balcony. I had a room that faced the street and is next to the elevator so it was noisy.'

'Great place!'