Strandhotels in Shelter Island

'The room was clean, a/c very cold, staff friendly/ helpful. Will stay again!'

'Staff was helpful. Place is quiet. Room was a little outdated.'

'easy access from highway and lot of parking'

'Klamme en vochtige kamer. Wij gaan er niet weer naar toe. Verouderde inrichting. Positief is de koelkast op de kamer. Handig met dit warme weer. Werkelijkheid en foto's site komen niet overeen. '

'Great place,great town !!'

'The Inn at Harbor Hill Marina was a huge surprise. We arrived to a very friendly accomodating staff, who had set up an evening of wine & cheese from their lawn, decks and porch looking over the harbor while a guitarist played and sang from the gazebo. Staff were attentive and informative. We foolishly skipped the inn's pontoon cruise upriver because we were too relaxed to walk down to the dock. But the people who took the cruise really enjoyed it. Our room was spotless. It was spacious enough...

'Loved the beautiful porch and closeness to beach. The bed and linens were so comfortable.'

'DO NOT STAY AT THIS HOTEL. There was a drunk or stoned individual sitting on the staircase by the front door when we drove in. (See attached photo.) When I walked into the lobby (which was a mess and smelled), a young woman had been waiting for nearly half an hour for a receptionist to show up. I pressed the buzzer repeatedly. No response from any staff member. The young lady who had been waiting told me she had stayed at this hotel before and said it was terrible. She strongly recommended that...