Strandhotels in Shelter Island

'Before our arrival, the host provided clear driving directions, recommended great restaurants, and shared helpful tips for accessing the beach and finding parking. She even asked if we’d like fresh fruit, so when we arrived, we found a bowl of fruit waiting for us, bottled water in the refrigerator, and the air conditioning and fan already running to keep the space cool and comfortable. The place was spotless, well-maintained, and conveniently located close to everything we needed. The host’s...

'Great!!'

'Comfortable Bed. Clean bathroom. Peaceful stay.'

'Horrible room, foul odor in the bathroom, and the door didn’t close, no soap, no tissues, no coffee maker. Run, don’t walk, away from this place.'

'Klamme en vochtige kamer. Wij gaan er niet weer naar toe. Verouderde inrichting. Positief is de koelkast op de kamer. Handig met dit warme weer. Werkelijkheid en foto's site komen niet overeen. '

'Very cute cottage that was recently remodeled. We liked: the location, nicely decorated, kitchen with coffee pot, oven and fridge, the passes to Waterford Beach, the rec room, Responsive staff, the outdoor area with swing sets, picnic bench, huge yard. Although cottage #22 has 2 bedrooms, I would not recommend this unit for 2 adults and teens, it is too small. Warning - the hot water takes time to heat up. The cottage has a small air condition unit is in the kitchen only so the bedrooms were...

'The woman at the front desk was very polite and helpful. The room wasn't the cleanest, there was either dust and/or mold on the valance and curtains. The floor was dirty, had to walk around with shoes or flip flops on because my feet were filthy from walking for 5 minutes. Looked like smeared blood on the wall and saw possibly a roach in the room.'

'This is not a hotel. The room is clean, but it is extremely noisy. Room 1 is located directly above a billiard bar, making it very difficult to rest. There is no reception and no parking available. Overall, there is a lot of noise and the experience was disappointing.'