Strandhotels in Shelter Island

'The room was very clean and the beds were extremely comfortable. The pool is around back and you have to walk all the way around the building to get to it but that said though not convenient, it was private back there. Shower was adequate but not great. All and all good experience and very reasonably priced.'

'Whenever I'm traveling thru Southern CT on business, the Lamplighter is my go to for staying over. Clean room. Comfortable bed, plenty of Hot Water, microwave and mini fridge, good TV. Reasonable price, close to the highway. Restaurants within walking distance. It has it all.'

'Before our arrival, the host provided clear driving directions, recommended great restaurants, and shared helpful tips for accessing the beach and finding parking. She even asked if we’d like fresh fruit, so when we arrived, we found a bowl of fruit waiting for us, bottled water in the refrigerator, and the air conditioning and fan already running to keep the space cool and comfortable. The place was spotless, well-maintained, and conveniently located close to everything we needed. The host’s...

'Klamme en vochtige kamer. Wij gaan er niet weer naar toe. Verouderde inrichting. Positief is de koelkast op de kamer. Handig met dit warme weer. Werkelijkheid en foto's site komen niet overeen. '

'Good.'

'Dit hotel is verouderd en het stinkt overal naar sigarettenrook. Er was verl geluid van de snelweg. En het onbijt was armzalig...wit brood met alleen jam of pindakaas. Wat fruit en ern muffin. Zeker geen aanrader'

'This is a self-service hotel. No staff to check in or help in any way. And no parking. Avoid. You can do better'

'Great place,great town !!'