Strandhotels in Shelter Island

'It’s a beautiful property with a fun bar and delicious restaurant . The rooms were beautiful and the bed was super comfortable'

'Room clean, bed comfy, high quality towels, friendly and accommodating customer service. Great areas in hotel to sit, read, relax Great location'

'We stayed at the Shoals for 3 nights. Something I didn't realize was that there are no rooms directly facing the water - all rooms look out to the parking lot. The property and rooms were very clean and very well maintained, however many things were lacking. 1.) MAJOR concern: We asked for a pack n play for our baby and they brought up a mattress with it. We looked up the mattress brand (Spring Spirit) and it was recalled in 2024!! Parents: please check all the items you receive!! We were...

'Unique place but service too dependent on the individual server or concierge - some are incredible others are too slow and thereby under the level of this kind of accomodation '

'There is no where to sit outside at night unless you have a room with a balcony. I had a room that faced the street and is next to the elevator so it was noisy.'

'Quiet, clean, good hospitality, private beach.'

'The hotel doesn’t reception doesn’t open till 9am. For early risers we had to leave the hotel just to get coffee. 9am is unheard of for a hotel'